Homeowners Push Back on Oversized Casitas

Key Points:

  • ADU Growth Sparks Backlash: A new Arizona law has made it easier to build backyard casitas (ADUs), fueling a boom in construction across Phoenix-area neighborhoods.
  • Homeowner Concerns:
    • Residents in Phoenix and Peoria have raised objections to oversized, multi-story structures.
    • Common complaints include violations of HOA CC&Rs and disruptions to neighborhood character.
  • Alternative Uses Stir Tension: Some casitas are being built for uses other than housing—like gyms, garages, or home offices, which adds to the tension.
  • Legal Pathways:
    • Projects require both city approval and separate HOA approval.
    • Homeowners may have legal standing to challenge projects that violate community rules.

Arizona Investor Insights:

  • HOAs Remain a Barrier: Even if state or city laws are favorable, HOAs can still restrict or block construction.
  • Opportunity in Compliance: Investors can position themselves as compliant, community-friendly builders, especially in HOA-regulated areas.
  • Risk Mitigation Strategy: Work with a property manager familiar with municipal and HOA zoning to avoid costly legal pushback.