How to Screen Potential Tenants in Arizona

How to Screen Potential Tenants in Arizona

December 16, 2025

Screening tenants the right way helps you avoid costly problems while staying compliant with Arizona law. Here’s what to do:

1️⃣ Follow Arizona & Federal Fair Housing Laws

  • You cannot discriminate based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, national origin, or familial status.
  • Some Arizona cities (like Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe) add protections for sexual orientation, gender identity, and source of income (like housing vouchers).
  • Apply the same written criteria to every applicant.

2️⃣ Use a Written Application

  • Every adult (18+) must complete a separate application.
  • Include full names, birth dates, current addresses, income sources, and consent for background screening.

3️⃣ Verify Identity

Acceptable IDs include:

  • Driver’s license, U.S. passport, military ID, green card, or other valid government photo ID.
  • Applicants must show legal presence in the U.S.

4️⃣ Confirm Income & Employment

  • Require at least 3× monthly rent in gross income.
  • Accept pay stubs, bank statements, job offer letters, or tax returns.
  • Self-employed applicants can show business bank statements or prior tax filings.

5️⃣ Review Credit Responsibly

  • Run a soft credit check.
  • Watch for unpaid housing debts, utility collections, recent bankruptcies, or payday loan defaults.
  • A clean, responsible history outweighs a perfect score.

6️⃣ Check Criminal History Fairly

  • Deny for recent violent or drug-manufacturing felonies (within 5 years).
  • Consider older or non-violent convictions case-by-case.
  • Registered sex offenders are automatically denied.

7️⃣ Verify Rental History

  • Confirm no evictions in the past 3 years.
  • No outstanding rent owed to prior landlords.
  • No more than 2 late payments or 1 NSF check per year.

8️⃣ Review Pets & Assistive Animals

  • Require photos and vaccination records for pets.
  • Limit to 4 pets per home.
  • Follow HUD guidelines for service and emotional support animals — these are not “pets” under the law.

9️⃣ Understand Occupancy Limits

  • Two people per bedroom + one additional person is considered reasonable.
  • Some cities, like Tempe, limit unrelated roommates to three.

🔟 Keep Records & Stay Consistent

  • Document why each application was approved or denied.
  • Never accept cash without paper trail.
  • Stay within A.R.S. § 33-1321 to § 33-1368 for security deposits, leases, and tenant obligations.

Bottom line:
Screening is your first line of defense against late rent and property damage. Be thorough, be consistent, and stay compliant.

Share: